Post any ideas / suggestions for the game servers here.
  • User avatar
  • User avatar
  • User avatar
  • User avatar

Should a torch in your hand emit light?

Well, yeah.
9
56%
No, that makes way too much sense.
7
44%
User avatar
By cerevox
#9754
Actually, this is never going to happen not because of the coding but because of its effect on the sever. Can you imagine the server having to recalcualte light values every single time a player moves? It would rape the server majorly and if it didn't crash it constantly it would at the very least lag it horribly.

Beyond that, the very idea itself sucks for the following reasons.

Torches are assumed to be unlit while in your hands. Otherwise they would be effect weapons, but as it is they are nothing more than sticks.

Also, if they produced light while in your hands, you should be able to set things on fire by striking a block with the torch. This would make flint and steel obsolete and change the whole balance of the game.

As for the coding itself, you might ignore it, but no one else will, so you can just skip this section if you think coding it doesn't matter. Actually creating a moving light source like this would require the server to have an invisible light block for each player and it would have to constantly check the players position and what they are holding and update the position of the light block over and over, which would be fairly easy to code but it would be an immense hit on the server resources, which are already sapped by re-calculating the light levels every time someone moves.

Seriously, icarus, did you even think for one second about this idea? Its terrible on all levels, not just the ones you like to ignore.

Edit: Of, and this would mean you only need one torch to explore an entire cave system. Even more game balance breaking changes.

Edit2: Biased poll much? I would vote against this solely on the grounds of the way you worded the poll, as if the other reasons were not overwhelming.
User avatar
By cerevox
#9757
He won't and he shouldn't. Being impulsive and refusing to check your own work isn't a bannable offense. Nor is posting crappy ideas.
User avatar
By Cogohst
#9758
icarus1080 wrote:
Kojaimea wrote:
catsfuzz wrote:I think it would be cool but I voted no because that would make spelunking WAY to easy!
Well logically torches should not work under water...
lol! Spelunking has nothing to do with water.
This may be a bit off topic, but most caves irl are made by underground running water whittling away at the rock. So spelunking has everything to do with water :P
By snitalvixzon
#9760
cerevox wrote:He won't and he shouldn't. Being impulsive and refusing to check your own work isn't a bannable offense. Nor is posting crappy ideas.
He post five stupid ideas a week and calls everyone who points out flaws in his idea a troll. I think he deserves one.
User avatar
By savesthedazed
#9768
snitalvixzon wrote:
cerevox wrote:He won't and he shouldn't. Being impulsive and refusing to check your own work isn't a bannable offense. Nor is posting crappy ideas.
He post five stupid ideas a week and calls everyone who points out flaws in his idea a troll. I think he deserves one.
I think most people don't give a darn what you think.

The idea isn't terrible. But it probably won't ever be implemented by Intelli. If anything, maybe someday Notch will add it to the game, but from what I've read here and elsewhere (http://getsatisfaction.com/mojang/topic ... le_torches), that also does not seem likely. At any rate, I like torches as if. It's nice to have limitations.
By snitalvixzon
#9772
savesthedazed wrote:
snitalvixzon wrote:
cerevox wrote:He won't and he shouldn't. Being impulsive and refusing to check your own work isn't a bannable offense. Nor is posting crappy ideas.
He post five stupid ideas a week and calls everyone who points out flaws in his idea a troll. I think he deserves one.
I think most people don't give a darn what you think.

The idea isn't terrible. But it probably won't ever be implemented by Intelli. If anything, maybe someday Notch will add it to the game, but from what I've read here and elsewhere (http://getsatisfaction.com/mojang/topic ... le_torches), that also does not seem likely. At any rate, I like torches as if. It's nice to have limitations.
If he would give details regarding the idea I wouldn't call it stupid. And he makes the poll say his idea his "cool" anyways no matter what you think.
User avatar
By Sharingan616
#9774
You can download a mod for this yourself, just it won't work for others and it may be considered an exploit.
Please stop posting suggestions.
By icarus1080
#9799
Alright! Well as far as what people have said about the idea itself, I agree. This seems to be something that would have to be client-side, since it would be a pretty silly thing to have the server keeping track of.

Looking back, I think most of my ideas might have been better suited for Notch anyway. Really I think they should just hire Intelli. Minerealm > Minecraft.
User avatar
By Cogohst
#9818
icarus1080 wrote:Alright! Well as far as what people have said about the idea itself, I agree. This seems to be something that would have to be client-side, since it would be a pretty silly thing to have the server keeping track of.

Looking back, I think most of my ideas might have been better suited for Notch anyway. Really I think they should just hire Intelli. Minerealm > Minecraft.
You gain 20 internets for listening to other's criticisms for once. Make it a habit, and there are more to come.
long long title how many chars? lets see 123 ok more? yes 60

We have created lots of YouTube videos just so you can achieve [...]

Another post test yes yes yes or no, maybe ni? :-/

The best flat phpBB theme around. Period. Fine craftmanship and [...]

Do you need a super MOD? Well here it is. chew on this

All you need is right here. Content tag, SEO, listing, Pizza and spaghetti [...]

Lasagna on me this time ok? I got plenty of cash

this should be fantastic. but what about links,images, bbcodes etc etc? [...]