[TechnoProdigy]

No I do not want a creative server. I want a server where I can gather resources and build large structures in peace without ever having to worry about other people interrupting me. Creative is not fun simply because I am handed all the items, I like having to go out and gather items, it keeps me from becoming bored of minecraft. PVP however just does not appeal to me and I think it has no place in the main world. In the Nether that's fine because 1.) I never go there and 2.) It's always had PVP.

So wait? you are saying that this shouldn't be implemented purely for the fact of your own beneficial needs?

I wouldn't be the only person to benefit from this, I'm sure a lot of people feel the same. That they do not wish to be interrupted while working in public realms. I am saying it shouldn't be implemented because there is no reason to implement it. You seem to want PVP just so you can go around killing people, if either of us want this implemented or not implemented for personal beneficial needs it seems to be you. Why inconvenience everyone else just so you can have your PVP which is already present in an entire other world of the game? (Nether)

Edit: You have the nether for PVP, we have the main world for building and resource gathering.

[Wxclm]

No I do not want a creative server. I want a server where I can gather resources and build large structures in peace without ever having to worry about other people interrupting me. Creative is not fun simply because I am handed all the items, I like having to go out and gather items, it keeps me from becoming bored of minecraft. PVP however just does not appeal to me and I think it has no place in the main world. In the Nether that's fine because 1.) I never go there and 2.) It's always had PVP.

So wait? you are saying that this shouldn't be implemented purely for the fact of your own beneficial needs?

I wouldn't be the only person to benefit from this, I'm sure a lot of people feel the same. That they do not wish to be interrupted while working in public realms. I am saying it shouldn't be implemented because there is no reason to implement it. You seem to want PVP just so you can go around killing people, if either of us want this implemented or not implemented for personal beneficial needs it seems to be you. Why inconvenience everyone else just so you can have your PVP which is already present in an entire other world of the game? (Nether)

You're still not understanding where i am coming from. Firstly, i don't want this for PVP. I want this to make the game more fun and exciting for everyone. In 2.0 it was great, the game was exciting when you had to make a journey somewhere and know that if someone would appear, you may need to fight like it is in real life. Secondly, the reason for this is to not allow people to kill each other over and over again, but to make the game more vanilla. The game of Minecraft was built to have PVP everywhere. So it is not implementing it, but rather removing the protection that you were so kindly given when Intelli created the 3.0 update.

[TechnoProdigy]

You people constantly trying to make Minerealm more "Vanilla" is beginning to get a little ridiculous.

[CraigParton]

No.

Obviously people who enjoy PVP more than mining or building think the change will be "fun" or "exciting". What it really means they can go around and kill people and take their resources so they don't have to go out and dig for them. Having someone sneak up and kill you while you're digging is not my idea of entertainment. So now I have to go mining in diamond armor and PVP gear? Thanks but no thanks. Oh, but you'll be safe in a realm! I usually don't go mining in my realms since most of the resources are already gone.

I already read way too much crap in the chat when people whine about dying in the Nether.

[Surgeonbsg]

PVP everywhere isn't Vanilla. It's just another option Notch gave to server owners. There is a flag right in the config file to either have or not have PVP. Either option is "vanilla".

As far as PVP everywhere. Do NOT want! The subway goes through public land, I mine in public land, I gather wool and food in public land. I don't need to deal with potion spam and people running around in Diamond armor while I'm trying to do that. All this is is another way for the trolls to get people to rage and get free goods so they don't have to actually work for them. And no I don't call killing someone work.

[OtherKitty]

i agree with Technoprodigy. i have several realms far away from each other and i already face a challenge in getting from one to the another, they are called mobs. i risk whatever i am transferring whenever i come across a creeper. you may not plan on spending all your time stalking innocent bystanders, but there would be people that ALL they would do is make it their only mission... to kill and take our stuff. i play in single player, which is the original vanilla isn't it? i have never came across a person camped out waiting to kill me, not once. the mobs are enough for me, thank you!

i think minerealm has enough as it is to satisfy each kind of player. we have the nether for pvp and also arenas for it. i hate it and avoid the nether most of the time, but i don't think pvp should be not allowed there just because of i don't like it. but i also think that we should not be subjected to in the general overworld just because some of you want it. if it is that important to you go play on one of the pvp servers.

many of my realms are waaay out in the wilderness, and most of the time i do not see people. BUT if this change were to occur, i bet i would see many more people wandering around looking to see who they can kill.

[guadalcanal1]

I would enjoy this idea, however, there would be some difficulties:
CONS

1: NTC would play for 24/7 and try to kill every noob
2: Many players would probably log off when attacked, creating bans and animosity
3: Some players would never stop complaining, causing a constant annoyance to mods and admins

PROS

1: Adds a new challenge to the wilderness
2: It would make large scale wars easier and more fun
3: It would make it more necessary to buy realms

All in all, I am for this idea

[MrPacman]

1: NTC would play for 24/7 and try to kill every noob

Because everyone in NTC obviously has no life outside of minecraft, and does nothing other than PVP in the nether.

I'm against this idea, because I don't want to be killed while I'm building. the Nether is enough PVP for me.

And Yes, I would very much like to have a creative server again, so don't bother quoting my post and saying that.

[mitch1423]

I think this would be more fun than the current almost unused pvp system.

[jeniansmom]

If put to a vote, I would vote no. I play on MineRealm because it's PVE not PVP. I respect that other people have different game play styles/desires and think that the /pvp option and the nether are good compromises.