[BSGSamuel]

This kind of defeats the point of an unprotected nether. If you want to build a protected city you might as well do it in the overworld.

All that's going to happen is that more and more people will want a protected area in the nether as well and before you know it you basically have a realm system in the nether.

I know you only want one city controlled by a couple of players but it seems unfair to give a couple of people that advantage above everyone else.

[SilsuCrow]

This kind of defeats the point of an unprotected nether. If you want to build a protected city you might as well do it in the overworld.

All that's going to happen is that more and more people will want a protected area in the nether as well and before you know it you basically have a realm system in the nether.

I know you only want one city controlled by a couple of players but it seems unfair to give a couple of people that advantage above everyone else.

The idea behind the protection is not to give one group of people a leg up over another group, it's to cut down on griefing and give the mods a break from having to always come in to roll back damage. As per the edit on the first post, the city itself will be owned solely by the mods and admins who will divvy up building rights to the major factions.

What you are proposing is a slippery slope argument. "OMG THEY HAVE A PROTECTED CITY, I WANT A PROTECTED CITY" and so on and so on until they have to convert all of the Nether. The idea is that this will be a landmark. Something permanent and beautiful in the sea of chaos that is the Nether. I am not advocating for the roads or Nether portals to be protected, just this one slice of Nether which, as Intelli mentioned (somewhere) will be expanded come the wipe.

Regardless of protection approval or not, I will still be moving to have this city built. It'll just be more taxing on the mods and admins who have to roll back the damages from griefers.

[Cannabin0l]

Someone made a suggestion that Dis should be ~200x200 (4x4 "realms"). If we go with that, the proper city would be in the center four "realms" and each "faction" would get one of the "spokes" around Dis. Doing so would allow each faction to have full building rights in their own faction's realm while at the same time allowing for representation within the city.

+123

So far, the only two factions that are running the nether (in so many words), are Ceteri and NTC.

[SilsuCrow]

Someone made a suggestion that Dis should be ~200x200 (4x4 "realms"). If we go with that, the proper city would be in the center four "realms" and each "faction" would get one of the "spokes" around Dis. Doing so would allow each faction to have full building rights in their own faction's realm while at the same time allowing for representation within the city.

+123

So far, the only two factions that are running the nether (in so many words), are Ceteri and NTC.

True, but with 8 more realms to fill, I'm sure we could fit some more factions in =3

[Cannabin0l]

Someone made a suggestion that Dis should be ~200x200 (4x4 "realms"). If we go with that, the proper city would be in the center four "realms" and each "faction" would get one of the "spokes" around Dis. Doing so would allow each faction to have full building rights in their own faction's realm while at the same time allowing for representation within the city.

+123

So far, the only two factions that are running the nether (in so many words), are Ceteri and NTC.

True, but with 8 more realms to fill, I'm sure we could fit some more factions in =3

If this happens I'd be so happy. It would put an end to the griefing and complaining that's for sure.

[SilsuCrow]

Someone made a suggestion that Dis should be ~200x200 (4x4 "realms"). If we go with that, the proper city would be in the center four "realms" and each "faction" would get one of the "spokes" around Dis. Doing so would allow each faction to have full building rights in their own faction's realm while at the same time allowing for representation within the city.

+123

So far, the only two factions that are running the nether (in so many words), are Ceteri and NTC.

True, but with 8 more realms to fill, I'm sure we could fit some more factions in =3

If this happens I'd be so happy. It would put an end to the griefing and complaining that's for sure.

Well the city is gonna happen. Can't say for certain about the protection though....

[SilsuCrow]

Updated the first post greatly. Also took out the poll. Will put it back in on the weekend after the sketches are up.

[SilsuCrow]

Updated the first post with a quick sketch.
Re added the poll and changed the title to bring attention to the first post.