- Fri Sep 11, 2015 8:40 pm
#195026
I strongly disagree with his claim about the lack of necessary strategy. It gets pretty darn tough, and you have to not only play the game (how many should I train, where should I put them, which spells should I use, when should I activate hero abilities, etc.), but also the meta-game. Should I break my shield? What should I upgrade first? Should I upgrade Air Defenses one at a time and be somewhat vulnerable for a while, or all at once and be extremely vulnerable for a short time? Should I spend my Dark Elixir on troops or my Barbarian King? How I can time my builders so that I have a chance to dump gold into walls every day? Should I use this more effective army, or a weaker one that's much cheaper and takes way less time to train?
And if you mess up, it really does have consequences. I'm not going to claim that it takes an atypical amount of skill to advance through CoC, but it isn't supposed to. It's supposed to take dedication and a moderate amount of skill to make it accessible to your average mobile gamer, with the option of things like Clan Wars and Achievements for those who want a challenge. Plus, if you, for example, rush your Town Hall to a high level before upgrading army and defense buildings and troop upgrades, you're going to be screwed because a loot penalty forces you to raid mostly people of your same level, one below your level at the lowest. And if you can't do that, and you also can't get a significant amount of loot from low level people...well, let's just say that you're not going to be maxing out your walls any time soon. (Some people would say it's better to just start a new account if you mess up badly enough—like, for example, buying Gems and rushing straight to TH10. There's really nothing you can do at that point.)
It's no Skyrim, but it's got a lot more depth than that reviewer gives it credit for.
~dlgn
I am the whirring thing past the corner. I am the darker patch under the bed. I am the tapping on your window; the extra steps on the sidewalk; the voice whispering your name. I am Stalkerbot, and I am watching you.