Page 1 of 2

[REJECTED] Idea: Allow spawn realms to wipe individually

Posted: Wed Jan 22, 2014 3:40 pm
by ColdF3ar
Suggestion (also TLDR): Allow all owners of realms within 500 blocks of the spawn point to have the ability to individually wipe their realms through the use of /realm wipe command and exclude the 150x150 rule to avoid the red circles shown in the spoiler below.

What this would allow:
Spoiler:
Image

Also for those who forget:
Green & yellow realms are public or have had the /realm wipe command used on them.
Green realms will wipe fully
Yellow realms will be wiped and have the terrain merge applied to them
Blue realms are private and will not be wiped
White realms are public/set to be wiped but won't wipe due to the 150x150 rule
The realms in white that have been circled in the crude red photoshop job will not wipe even though the /realm wipe command has been used on them. With this suggestion, these realms will be allowed to wipe.

Why?: Besides making these realm owners happy that their builds will wipe, there are several advantages. Spawn realms are very coveted and have been long dug apart in their years of use. A growing majority of them have been hallowed to bedrock. Since wiping realms near spawn becomes a huge logistical issue and would only work if a large number of people got together, I am suggesting that spawn realms have the ability to be individually wiped. I think this would be a fun way for the community to start new builds at spawn and have start with a completely fresh realm.

Hopefully this might also encourage owners to raise their builds to a more even level. Once you walk past spawn the unevenness of realms becomes very noticeable. Having the first 500 or so blocks at the same level would hopefully concretize that this space is actually 'spawn city'.

Addressing concerns:
Patchy spawn grid - The reason the 150x150 rule was put into place was so that the map would not be patchy. However, any concerns about patchy unfitting realms can easily be addressed. Beacons with eff V and haste II and picks can make clearing a realm down flat to its neighbors a very simple task.

Pros: Makes realm owners in white happy. Adds fresh life to these realms that have been striped clean for possibly years. Hopefully encourages builds to be brought up to the y level of spawn and eliminate a bit of the unevenness which might help bring back the spawn roads.

Cons: Im sure Intelli is fairly swamped in coding as well as the amount of inquires about the wipe already. Adding and implementing this exclusion will take some time.

Re: Suggestion: Allow spawn realms to wipe individually

Posted: Wed Jan 22, 2014 3:42 pm
by diamond_boss
Yes.

Re: Suggestion: Allow spawn realms to wipe individually

Posted: Wed Jan 22, 2014 3:47 pm
by Grelman
I voted no simply because we're lucky its happening at all, and the acceptance of this suggestion could quite possibly delay the wipe further.

Whats more, we think spawn looks unpleasing now, imagine dotted realms raised about ten blocks higher than all the realms next to it. Especially if they are individual realms.

I would like the ability to do this but its just not very realistic.

Re: Suggestion: Allow spawn realms to wipe individually

Posted: Wed Jan 22, 2014 3:48 pm
by chammiefication
yesssss

Re: Suggestion: Allow spawn realms to wipe individually

Posted: Wed Jan 22, 2014 4:14 pm
by Taratsamura
isnt this suggestion Invalid?
because its about certain realms, and suggestions about certain realms arrent allowed in the Suggestions/Idea forum.

Ideas cannot involve specific players, times, or locations[...]

Re: Suggestion: Allow spawn realms to wipe individually

Posted: Wed Jan 22, 2014 4:20 pm
by Benstir
i voted no. It isn't fair to other players who live outside this zone and would like single realms to be disbanded.

Re: Suggestion: Allow spawn realms to wipe individually

Posted: Wed Jan 22, 2014 8:56 pm
by Eetrab
So... spawn extra diamonds near spawn, create an even larger burden on Intelli and make spawn even uglier than it is? Seems logical.

Re: Suggestion: Allow spawn realms to wipe individually

Posted: Thu Jan 23, 2014 12:25 am
by FinalFouad
The way I see it is that if you have a spawn realm, and would be primarily affected by this poll, then this poll is primarily for you.

Everyone knows spawn realms have always had different treatments versus other realms (e.g. if a spawn realm disbands, then you can purchase it without an application).

This is not for spawning extra diamonds. If a person has a spawn realm, they have no use for farming for diamonds in their spawn realms.

Re: Suggestion: Allow spawn realms to wipe individually

Posted: Thu Jan 23, 2014 12:42 am
by 11Hax
The circle most down and left in the spoiler with eight realms (2x4) is mine. I even own about half of the wiping area above that, and would really need to have those realms wiped to get that whole to be fit together for my future project.

For 'looking uglier" I can confirm that wont happen. Now its some flat realms with extreme hills on one side and some realms with huge cobble/netherrack builds on it.

Re: Suggestion: Allow spawn realms to wipe individually

Posted: Thu Jan 23, 2014 1:23 am
by 11Hax
Benstir wrote:i voted no. It isn't fair to other players who live outside this zone and would like single realms to be disbanded.
Thats communism. 'No one shall be allowed to have anything thats better than anyone else.'

Believe, I live in a socialist country, thats nit how you want MR to be :D