Page 1 of 1

[REJECTED] Allow players to petition for biome modification

Posted: Tue Dec 04, 2012 10:44 pm
by Prodigy9
Inspired by this thread.

The idea is that players can request that the staff change a specific biome to another biome. In order to qualify for this ability, players must first terraform the area to be similar to the desired biome. For example:
--If you want an ocean to be changed into a grassland, you should first cover at least the surface of the ocean with grass.
--If you want an extreme hills biome turned into a desert, you should first flatten the hills and replace the surface dirt/stone with sand.
--If you want a forest or jungle, plant lots of the appropriate tree types.

After terraforming, a biome change request can be posted on the forum. After posting the coordinates, desired change, and at least one screenshot of how it looks, staff can review the request and decide whether to change the biome. If a particular biome is home to multiple players, stretching from your realm into your neighbors, all residents must consent to the change--altering only a 50x50 area of a biome should not be allowed, as it would create excessively abrupt biome transitions that wouldn't look very nice.

There are a few benefits to being able to change a biome, including effects on mob spawning, being able to artificially introduce new biomes to Minerealm's main 10Kx10K map, adding/removing/changing weather type, and changing the color of grass that grows in the area.

Re: Allow players to petition for biome modification

Posted: Wed Dec 05, 2012 7:25 am
by EpicBros
I think its a good idea in theory, and I was coming up with something similar. However, I don't think it should be available to any other biome than ocean. Now if you've seen my previous thread you might be thinking thats selfish of me. And you would be right. But this of course affects other players than myself. I feel it wouldn't be very (god do I hate using this term but I can't think of a better way of putting it) vanilla to make it so you basically have free reign over what biome you are dwelling.

The only reason the ocean change really works is for two factors/causes. 1 being if you were previously in a different, more hospitable biome prior to the 3.0 wipe. 2 is if you put the time in to teraform over an ocean.

I also feel that the choice for biome change should only be forest, due to it being fairly basic and not much changing from ocean.

Re: Allow players to petition for biome modification

Posted: Wed Dec 05, 2012 8:29 pm
by Radio
Good idea in general.. But its not vanilla.. Goodluck anyways

Re: Allow players to petition for biome modification

Posted: Wed Dec 05, 2012 9:48 pm
by monkeychunks
When I meant you could change the biome it was a personal thing, but changing biomes otherwise is not legit

Re: Allow players to petition for biome modification

Posted: Wed Dec 05, 2012 9:52 pm
by Prodigy9
Radio wrote:Good idea in general.. But its not vanilla.. Goodluck anyways
I admit that it's not entirely vanilla (though neither are realms and credits, remember ;) ), but this is similar to something proposed by Intelli as an alternative way to approach an extremely non-vanilla suggestion (changing how biomes act with regard to animal spawning). Although the act of changing a biome's identity is not part of the usual Minecraft experience, the biome created by such a modification would behave exactly the same as its natural counterparts.

Re: Allow players to petition for biome modification

Posted: Thu Dec 06, 2012 5:04 pm
by cubeguy314
So, I could cover my whole realm in mycelium and make it a mushroom biome?! (If this were implemented, that is)

Re: Allow players to petition for biome modification

Posted: Thu Dec 06, 2012 5:05 pm
by Intelli
cubeguy314 wrote:So, I could cover my whole realm in mycelium and make it a mushroom biome?! (If this were implemented, that is)
Yea, I disagree with this suggestion.

What I was suggesting in the other thread was for biome corrections, for biomes that were incorrectly changed in the old map wipe.

Re: Allow players to petition for biome modification

Posted: Thu Dec 06, 2012 5:19 pm
by dlgn
Normally, I'd oppose a chocolately suggestion like this, but since MineRealm is so incredibly scrambled and modified, I think that, in limited instances, players ought to be able to at least petition to have their biome changed.

~dlgn

Re: Allow players to petition for biome modification

Posted: Thu Dec 06, 2012 5:22 pm
by cubeguy314
If I could cover my realm in endstone... *Daydreams*