Page 1 of 2
[REJECTED]Suggestion:Tramplingfarmsonprivaterealmsbannable
Posted: Sat Nov 24, 2012 6:16 pm
by McFattyXXXL
"Trampling farms on owned realms should be veiwed as serious harassment" is what I am going for in this idea. But now that I think of it, it can be viewed as greifing since it does involve destroying something someone has built.
Here I am just minding my own business, then decided to go to my town of ravine to check up on my potatoe and carrot farm. Only to find them trampled and not there. Then found my wheat farm the same way. I absolutely felt harassed, just furious someone would do such a thing. A huge loss on my part since I dunno if mods can rollback my farms to back where they was, or if they can id the person who done it, and since I aqquired the potatoes and carrots via a giveaway and only receiving only a few each.
Re: Suggestion: Trampling farms on private realms bannable
Posted: Sat Nov 24, 2012 6:33 pm
by aidynn2001
i dont think it should result in a ban but a temporary ban of any legnth depend on how much property damaged would be better
Re: Suggestion: Trampling farms on private realms bannable
Posted: Sat Nov 24, 2012 6:36 pm
by Nephalem
I don't think a poll is needed as it is seen as griefing.
Destroying others things against their will on purpose is griefing and thereby bannable.
It's up for staff to decide when it's a warning and when it's a ban, they judge.
Re: Suggestion: Trampling farms on private realms bannable
Posted: Sat Nov 24, 2012 6:48 pm
by mr. roach
It's basically already bannable. You could add another passage way or block the crops so only members of that realm could access the crops.
Re: Suggestion: Trampling farms on private realms bannable
Posted: Sat Nov 24, 2012 6:51 pm
by McFattyXXXL
mr. roach wrote:It's basically already bannable. You could add another passage way or block the crops so only members of that realm could access the crops.
That is what I plan on doing once I am able to get my potatoes and carrots back, or if I do get them back. The wheat I can already replant since I got a stock of seeds for them, but the potatoes and carrot seeds was what I had in the garden. Might even put in underground.
Re: Suggestion: Trampling farms on private realms bannable
Posted: Sat Nov 24, 2012 9:13 pm
by nickisbestpony
McFattyXXXL wrote:mr. roach wrote:It's basically already bannable. You could add another passage way or block the crops so only members of that realm could access the crops.
That is what I plan on doing once I am able to get my potatoes and carrots back, or if I do get them back. The wheat I can already replant since I got a stock of seeds for them, but the potatoes and carrot seeds was what I had in the garden. Might even put in underground.
Its not like Carrots and Potatoes are some sort of rarity. I'll give you a stack of each, calm down.
Re: Suggestion: Trampling farms on private realms bannable
Posted: Mon Nov 26, 2012 6:27 am
by bcbarton
Here was Intelli's opinion about making crop trampling impossible
http://minerealm.com/community/viewtopi ... ple#p89924
Intelli wrote:heatsword2 wrote:You know whats funny, it never occored to you guys that you could easily put the roof lower so people cant trample it.
Pretty sure you can do this.
So considering there's already a "vanilla" gameplay solution for this, this idea will not be implemented.
It may have bearing on this issue when the "prevention" solution is the same.
Re: Suggestion: Trampling farms on private realms bannable
Posted: Mon Nov 26, 2012 9:08 am
by Roobean
nickisbestpony wrote:McFattyXXXL wrote:mr. roach wrote:It's basically already bannable. You could add another passage way or block the crops so only members of that realm could access the crops.
That is what I plan on doing once I am able to get my potatoes and carrots back, or if I do get them back. The wheat I can already replant since I got a stock of seeds for them, but the potatoes and carrot seeds was what I had in the garden. Might even put in underground.
Its not like Carrots and Potatoes are some sort of rarity. I'll give you a stack of each, calm down.

Re: Suggestion: Trampling farms on private realms bannable
Posted: Mon Nov 26, 2012 2:46 pm
by ghastly18
i think an easy way to fix this is to make it so you can't trample crops on a private realm you do not have access to. ( As in they wont break )
Re: Suggestion: Trampling farms on private realms bannable
Posted: Mon Nov 26, 2012 3:16 pm
by Radio
Redkiller123 wrote:I don't think a poll is needed as it is seen as griefing.
Destroying others things against their will on purpose is griefing and thereby bannable.
It's up for staff to decide when it's a warning and when it's a ban, they judge.
Yes, red is right^^^^^^^
I find this thread pointless since it is already considered griefing.. Sorry just my few cents worth.